fish tales market and eatery trip advisor pagefish tales market and eatery facebook

the fish tales story

Fish Tales Market & Eatery is the oldest Fish Market and Restaurant on Marathon Key. Located in the "Heart of the Keys", Fish Tales is not only a full service fish house, offering fresh fish, shrimp, stone crab, lobster and other local seafood, but hand cut aged choice and prime steaks as well. Homemade Bratwurst and Italian Sausage, cheeses, salsa and spreads are also available. Having a special get together? We can make up a party platter, or offer recipe ideas.

stop by fish tales market and eatery for fresh florida keys fish and seafood!Our restaurant serves up seafood "fresh from our market to your table", as well as burgers, steaks and homemade daily specials using only the freshest ingredients.

We pride ourselves in providing the best seafood products from the Florida Keys. Stop by and try some of our Award Winning Conch Salad, Fritters and Chowder, Lobster Bisque, George’s smoked fish spread, whole fresh key lime pie or Chef Johnny’s Rambler Sandwich, which was voted best fish sandwich in Marathon.

Be sure to have a look at our Menu today to find out why you should stop by Fish Tales when you are in the "Heart of the Florida Keys" or click here for our location and directions!

Once you are here, be sure to try one of our specialties from our kitchen:

  • Buffalo Shrimp
  • Fried Lobster Sandwich
  • Cracked Conch
  • Johnny's Fish Rambler
  • Smoked Fish (Family Recipe)
  • Award Winning Conch Salad